Great white sharks are one of the most fascinating creatures in the ocean. They are known for their massive size, incredible power, and fearsome reputation. However, despite their popularity, great white sharks are rarely seen in aquariums and many people wonder why.
One reason for the absence of great white sharks in aquariums is their size. Great white sharks can grow up to 20 feet long and weigh over 5,000 pounds. These massive creatures require a lot of space to move around and thrive. Most aquariums simply do not have the resources to accommodate such large animals.
Another reason is the difficulty of keeping great white sharks in captivity. These animals are apex predators that require a specific diet and environment to survive. They are also highly migratory and require a lot of space to swim. As a result, great white sharks have a low survival rate in captivity, making them challenging to maintain in aquariums.
Table of Contents
Overview of Great White Sharks
The great white shark (Carcharodon carcharias) is a species of shark that is known for its size, power, and predatory behavior. It is one of the most well-known shark species and is often referred to as an apex predator in the marine ecosystem.
Despite its popularity and notoriety, great white sharks have never been successfully kept in captivity in aquariums. This is due to a number of reasons, including their large size, complex social behavior, and unique physiological needs.
Great white sharks are one of the largest predatory fish in the ocean, with adult males reaching lengths of up to 20 feet and weighing as much as 5,000 pounds. This size makes them difficult to house in aquariums, as they require a large amount of space to swim and move around. Additionally, great white sharks are known to be social creatures, often traveling in groups or pairs, which makes it difficult to keep them in isolation.
Another reason why great white sharks have not been successfully kept in captivity is due to their unique physiological needs. These sharks require a constant flow of water to breathe, and they are also sensitive to changes in water temperature, salinity, and quality. Captivity can cause stress and health problems for these animals, which can lead to a shortened lifespan.
In addition to these challenges, there are also ethical considerations when it comes to keeping great white sharks in captivity. Wildlife advocates argue that these animals belong in the wild, where they can live and thrive in their natural environment. Captivity can cause stress and behavioral changes in these animals, which can be detrimental to their health and well-being.
The Challenges of Captivity
Keeping great white sharks in captivity is a difficult and controversial task due to a variety of challenges that aquariums face. These challenges include size and space requirements, dietary needs, nomadic behavior, and stress and well-being.
Size and Space Requirements
Great white sharks are the largest predatory fish in the ocean, and they require a lot of space to move around. In captivity, providing enough room for a great white shark to swim freely is nearly impossible. According to a study on captive feeding and growth of young-of-the-year white sharks at the Monterey Bay Aquarium, the tank size required to house a great white shark would be at least 1.2 million liters (317,000 gallons) of water. This amount of water is not feasible for most aquariums due to the high cost of resources required to maintain such a large tank.
Great white sharks are apex predators that feed on a variety of marine life, including fish, seals, and even other sharks. In captivity, providing a balanced diet that meets all of their dietary needs is a challenge. Additionally, captive sharks can develop a wasting disease if they are not fed a proper diet. According to a research article on sharks for the aquarium and considerations for their selection, some species like great white sharks do not adapt well to captivity due to difficulties in feeding them.
Great white sharks are nomadic and require vast open ocean environments to move around freely. In captivity, they are confined to a small tank, which can cause stress and lead to abnormal behavior. According to a study on sharks in captivity, the impetus to capture and keep a great white shark in captivity is often driven by financial gain rather than conservation efforts. This practice is often criticized as inhumane and unnecessary.
Stress and Well-Being
Captive great white sharks are often stressed due to the confined environment and lack of space to move around. This can lead to abnormal behavior, such as swimming in circles or banging their heads against the tank walls. According to a research article on sustainable species management of the elasmobranch populations within European aquariums, the well-being of captive sharks should be a top priority for aquariums, but it is often not a first priority.
The Difficulties of Capture and Transport
Great white sharks are notoriously difficult to capture due to their size, strength, and speed. Traditional fishing methods are not effective, and alternative methods such as baited hooks and nets have proven to be dangerous for both the sharks and the humans involved in the capture process.
One alternative method that has been used successfully is the use of acoustic tags. These tags emit a sound that attracts the sharks, allowing researchers to track and capture them without the use of hooks or nets. However, this method is expensive and requires a significant amount of time and resources.
Once captured, transporting great white sharks to aquariums presents a significant challenge. These sharks require large tanks with a constant flow of fresh seawater, which is difficult to replicate in a transport tank. Additionally, the stress of transport can cause health issues for the sharks, such as a decrease in oxygen levels and an increase in cortisol levels.
To minimize these risks, transport tanks must be carefully designed and maintained to ensure the sharks’ safety and well-being. The tanks must also be equipped with oxygenation systems and temperature control to maintain optimal conditions during transport.
Injuries and Risks
The capture and transport of great white sharks also poses significant risks to the humans involved. These sharks are powerful predators and can cause serious injury or death if proper safety protocols are not followed.
Injuries can also occur to the sharks during the capture and transport process. The stress of capture and transport can cause physical injuries, such as damage to the fins and gills, and can also lead to long-term health issues, such as decreased immune function and reproductive problems.
Attempts to Exhibit Great Whites
Despite being one of the most iconic and fascinating marine creatures, great white sharks have never been successfully exhibited in aquariums for long periods. This section explores some of the attempts to exhibit great whites in aquariums, including the Monterey Bay Aquarium, Steinhart Aquarium, and SeaWorld.
Monterey Bay Aquarium
The Monterey Bay Aquarium was the first aquarium to attempt to exhibit a great white shark in 2004. The aquarium kept a juvenile female great white shark in a million-gallon tank for 198 days, during which time it attracted over a million visitors. However, the shark died due to unknown causes, and the aquarium has not attempted to exhibit another great white shark since then.
The Steinhart Aquarium in San Francisco also attempted to exhibit a great white shark in 1984. The aquarium kept a juvenile great white shark in a tank for 16 days, during which time it refused to eat and eventually died. The aquarium’s director, David Powell, later stated that the shark’s death was due to stress caused by its confinement in the tank.
SeaWorld has also attempted to exhibit great white sharks in the past. In 1981, the company caught a juvenile great white shark and kept it in a tank for 16 days. However, the shark refused to eat and eventually died. SeaWorld has not attempted to exhibit another great white shark since then.
Despite these attempts, great white sharks have never been successfully exhibited in aquariums for long periods. According to an article on learning in zoos and aquariums, great white sharks are not suitable for captivity due to their size, predatory nature, and migratory behavior. The author suggests that zoos and aquariums should focus on educating the public about great white sharks through other means, such as interactive exhibits, virtual reality experiences, and live webcams.
The Impact on Ecosystem and Conservation Efforts
The absence of great white sharks in aquariums is not only due to their size and difficulty in captivity, but also due to the impact it would have on the ecosystem and conservation efforts. Great white sharks are apex predators and play a crucial role in maintaining the balance of the ocean’s ecosystem. Removing them from the open water could have a significant impact on the ecosystem and the animals that depend on them.
Aquariums are designed to simulate the natural environment of the animals they house, but it is impossible to recreate the vastness of the open ocean and the natural behaviors of these animals. Great white sharks are open ocean animals that require a large amount of space to swim and hunt. Keeping them in captivity could lead to stress, aggression, and even death.
Furthermore, great white sharks are not just any predators, they are mammals, and their life cycle is unique. They are slow to mature and have a low reproductive rate, making them vulnerable to overfishing and other threats. Conservation efforts are focused on protecting these animals in the wild and educating the public about their importance in the ecosystem.
In recent years, there has been a shift towards promoting citizen science and breeding programs as a way to support conservation efforts. Zoos and aquariums can play a role in educating audiences about great white sharks and the threats they face. However, they must do so without removing these animals from the wild or disrupting the balance of the ecosystem.